Skip to main content
 

We Buy Coins, Jewelry and Collectibles
Please call for appointments

Have an item and don't know its value? Send us an image with brief description and we'll tell you exactly what it's worth!

Online Appraisal

Learn the worth of up to 5 items for FREE!

Send photos and descriptions of each item and we’ll appraise their value online.

    Interviewed as Experts by:

    About Honest Coin Shop

    We share a passion for rare coins, currency, and other precious treasures. These items hold real value, teach us about history, and carry an intrinsic beauty. Our journey began as a small partnership with Hudson Valley Numismatics, offering appraisals, helping settle estates, and buying and selling individual pieces and large collections. Recognizing the growing demand from New Jersey residents, we expanded our reach by launching a service that caters specifically to collectors across the Garden State. Now, we proudly serve New Jersey and the entire Tri-State region with the expertise and care you deserve.

    Our mission is simple: to provide our New Jersey customers with trusted guidance, expert appraisals, and a seamless buying or selling experience. Whether you’re looking to invest in rare coins, build your collection, or sell valuable items, we offer personalized service every step of the way. We operate strictly by appointment, ensuring that each client receives the dedicated time and attention they deserve. With a deep understanding of the numismatic market and a commitment to integrity, we make sure that each transaction is transparent and rewarding.

    Read More About

    Customer’s Reviews

    Honest Coin
    Shop Always Buying!

    Honest Coin Shop utilizes the most transparent process of buying and selling in New Jersey.  We don’t intimidate or confuse our customers, but share the exact value and history of each item.

    Sell Now

    What We Buy

    At Honest Coin Shop, we specialize in purchasing a diverse array of collectibles and precious metals. We buy rare coins, including unique varieties and historical pieces, alongside gold and silver bullion in various forms. Our interest extends to numismatic items like U.S. and world paper currency, including large-size notes and collectible foreign banknotes. Additionally, we acquire fine jewelry and other collectibles. Bring us your treasures, and let’s uncover their true value together!

    Online Appraisal

    Learn the worth of up to 5 items for FREE!

    Send photos and descriptions of each item and we’ll appraise their value online. More than 5 items? Schedule an appointment for an in-person meeting with an expert.