We Buy Coins, Jewelry and Gold

Have an item and don't know its value? Send us an image with brief description and we'll tell you exactly what you have and exactly what it's worth!

We Buy Coins, Jewelry and Gold

We don't pressure our customers to sell, but give them the exact value and history behind each item. We offer top price for gold, silver, coins, and other valuable items in NYC, NJ, Long Island & Connecticut.

We Buy and Sell Precious Metals

We pay top dollar and we sell at the best prices in the New York Metropolitan area.

Precious Metals


Coins and Currency

We Are Always Buying!

Precious Metals   •   Gold   •   Gold Coins   •   Silver Coins   •   Rare Coins   •   Jewelry   •   Estate Jewelry

Honest Coin Shop utilizes the most transparent process of buying and selling in New York City, New Jersey, Long Island, and Connecticut. We don't intimidate or confuse our customers, but share the exact value and history of each item.

We share your love for rare and priceless items!

We Pay The Most In The Area when you sell your collectibles and valuable items. We'll appraise, review each item, and make an honest offer. Then, when you're ready to sell, we'll be here to buy!

We pay top dollar in the New York Metropolitan Area for rare coins!

Coin Coin Coin Coin Coin

Our partners for Rare Coin & Currency Consulting in the Hudson Valley!

Online Appraisal

Learn the worth of up to 5 items for FREE!

Send photos and descriptions of each item and we'll appraise their value online.

More than 5 items? Schedule an appointment for an in-person meeting with an expert.

We'll never share your email with anyone else.
We'll call instead of email if you leave your number.
How should we reach you?

Join the HCS Newsletter!