At Honest Coin Shop in Hoboken, most people know us for buying and appraising rare coins, gold, and silver. But did you know we also purchase a wide variety of vintage collectibles?
Whether you’re clearing out an attic, settling an estate, or just downsizing, we encourage you to take a closer look at those “old” items — they might be worth more than you think.
🎩 What Kind of Collectibles Do We Buy?
Over the years, we’ve developed a strong interest in unique and valuable vintage items, including:
Military Memorabilia – Medals, badges, dog tags, trench art, patches, and gear from past wars
Vintage Watches & Pocket Watches – Mechanical, wind-up, or unusual brands
Antique Jewelry – Gold, silver, or even high-end costume jewelry from decades past
Silverware & Flatware – Sterling and weighted silver sets or individual pieces
Vintage Pens & Lighters – Brands like Zippo, Parker, Cross, Dunhill, etc.
Old Political Pins & Campaign Buttons – Especially pre-1960s
Vintage Tools & Knives – Pocket knives, barber razors, hand tools with character
Pre-1980s Toys & Games – Tin toys, die-cast cars, original boxed board games
Advertising Signs & Tins – Gasoline, soda, tobacco, or general store items
Unusual Finds – Oddities that make you think, “Hmm, maybe this is collectible?”
If you’re not sure what you have, just ask — we’re always happy to take a look.
🤝 Why Sell to a Local Expert?
Selling locally means you skip the hassle of online listings, shipping, and guessing at values. At Honest Coin Shop, you’ll get a fair and honest offer based on market demand and real experience. Walk-ins are welcome, and appointments are preferred, so you get one-on-one attention and discretion.
So whether you’ve got a coin collection and some cool old collectibles — or just some mystery items you uncovered in a drawer — don’t toss them before giving us a call or stopping by our office at 46 Newark St, Suite 201, Hoboken, above Barsky Gallery.
We’re always looking to buy!
